Monday, May 20, 2013

Energy Savings

HERS Rating: 57% Improvement over Code  (What is a HERS rating?)


Projection: 80% Improvement over Code
  • load calculations from HVAC engineer of the highly efficient geo-thermal system together with infrequent usage of the system due to the Owner's preference for the designed natural ventilation
  • ceiling fans
  • CFL Energy Star and low-wattage LED fixture
  • all Energy Star appliances
  • ERV (what is an ERV?)
  • Rainwater collection pumps
  • Photovoltaic production contributing to Net Usage




Actual: 85% Improvement 
  • One year of energy bills logged and added up



Rainshine's actual energy consumption for 2010, the first full year of occupied operation, is remarkable.
The 2008 HERS (Home Energy Rating System) rating projected only a 57% improvement over code for RainShine.  Not pleased with the HERS rating we chose to conduct our own calculations and projected usage averaging $71.22 per month, an 80% improvement over a code compliant house.

We were confident in our numbers and knew HERS did not consider a variety of factors contributing to energy consumption. Among them:
1. The microclimate of the house
2. The extensive passive solar feature such the overhanging eaves, light shelves and east/west windows located to reduce solar gain through screening from existing trees.
3. The critical factor of the willingness of the clients to live a sustainable life in a sustainable house.

To prove our calculations we tracked the house's actual occupied energy consumption and photovoltaic production for 2010. Average gross utility cost per month was $48.57, an 85% improvement over code. A few more photovoltaic panels and the house would be net zero. 

The most disappointing result from our survey was photovoltaic production. Our calculations were based on a site specific calculation provided by the manufacturer who estimated (conservatively according to them) generation of 7,500 kWh/yr. Only 3,155 kWh were generated in 2010, less than half of the projection and a shortfall of $740 for the year and an average of $60 per month. If the PVs had performed up to snuff the house would easily be net zero. 

Conclusion: energy projections can be, as we all know, misleading and every house should be tracked to determine actual energy consumption. In general we were delighted with Rainshine's real-life performance. Rainshine proves how energy efficient thoughtfully combining site features, orientation, passive solar design concepts with active systems can be (even when incorporating major areas of glass). Kudos to the owner and design team!

Throwing features and systems at house designs in order to improve energy performance is, as I suspect HERS is necessarily dumbed down to do, wasteful and counterproductive. As in Rainshine an energy efficient house should look like an energy efficient house, not a neo-eclectic mishmash with energy features screwed in/tacked on a sideways compromising manner.

Monday, May 13, 2013

Goal 6 - Shady Screen Porch


  • Goal 6 - Shady screened porch for summer use
  • Preserve trees and locate on shadiest portion of site



Monday, May 6, 2013

Goal 5 - Sunny Back Porch

  • Goal 5 - Shade in summer, sunlight in winter for an open south facing backyard porch





Monday, April 22, 2013

Goal 3 - Rainwater Collection


  • Goal 3 - Collect rainwater for household use
  • Roof design simplifies collection of rainwater
  • LEED credit for impermeable site
    • SS4.1 Permeable Lot
      • RainShine House built site characteristics:
      • SA   Site area                                          15,747.0 sq.ft.
      • ISS   Impermeable site surfaces               397.5 sq. ft.      (exclusive of areas under roof)
      • VL   Vegetative landscape                  15,369.5 sq. ft.      (vegetative landscape)
      •  97.6%  Is collected or Permeable
      • 2.4% Is impermeable, 100% of all RainShine House impermeable site surfaces (Iss) are designed to direct all runoff toward permanent infiltration features (see site plan).










Friday, March 22, 2013

Beyond a Better Box

What the envelope can do for you.

On Wednesday, March 13, 2013, Robert M Cain, FAIA, presented to the attendees at Greenprints 2013 a gestalt of how modern design and sustainable design are not mutually exclusive.  The LEED Platunim-rated RainShine House in Decatur, Georgia was the case study.  The presentation addresses the six goals of the RainShine House design and how they were achieved.  Each goal is illustrated diagramatically and photographically, with LEED references and resources.

Envelope Goals established with Owner input

1.  Bring as much winter sunlight as possible into the house to counter the Owner's seasonal affective disorder

2.  Extend the times fo the year when the house can use natural ventilation instead of heating and cooling

3.  Collect rainwater for household use

4.  Design the house to incorporate photovoltaic modules

5.  Shade in Summer, sunlight in Winter for an open South-facing backyard porch

6.  Shady screened porch for Summer use

View a clip of Robert M. Cain, FAIA speaking about Greenprints

View the whole presentation


Thursday, November 19, 2009

Passive Solar Techniques in Diagram







Tuesday, April 28, 2009

Official LEED Platinum Press Release

One of the most nontoxic new single-family houses in the United States, The RainShine House in Decatur, Georgia has achieved, and exceeded, the highest level of “green architecture” possible through the United States Green Building Council’s LEED [Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design] for Homes Pilot Program. It is the first modernist residence to achieve the much-coveted LEED Platinum level in the Southeastern United States.

Also qualifying in other “green” architecture programs, the home is a certified EarthCraft Home and Energy Star home and currently a candidate for certification by the US Department of Energy under their Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy program.

The RainShine House was designed for a couple as their retirement residence with provision for visiting children and extended family members. The simple elegance of the design is achieved through fine detailing and an EarthCraft builder who worked diligently to achieve the wonderful qualities of the design of Robert M. Cain, Architect of Atlanta. Robert Soens, Jr. of Pinnacle Custom Builders said, “It was truly a privilege to work on this project with this superb design team, these wonderful owners and our LEED provider, Southface Institute”.

Certified in April 2009, the RainShine House will be featured in the popular Modern Atlanta Home Tour on May 16-17 so everyone can visit the home. This is the last time this exceptional residence will be open to the general public. The members of Modern Atlanta, a nonprofit promoting modern design in Atlanta, were invited to view the eco-friendly systems earlier this year for a pre-drywall tour showcasing the home’s systems and construction. Nearly 100 individuals came to view the five 500-gallon rainharvest cisterns in the basement, waterbased insulation materials, geothermal heat pump, desuperheaters, energy recovery ventilator, LED lighting system and the net-metered, roof-mounted 3.1 kilowatt photovoltaic system. RainShine will also be featured in the Decatur, Georgia GREENFEST tour of homes this year during the weekend of May 2. This home is so energy efficient that it is anticipated it will consume only 43% of the energy consumed by a similar home built to the standards of the International Energy Conservation Code.

RainShine’s most stunning feature is the soaring butterfly roof designed to facilitate collection of rain water for the rainharvest system. To accommodate the long spans of the butterfly roof, the roof of the home is framed in 100% recycled-content steel from local sources; this material was also chosen because it is easily recycled and mold, mildew and termite resistant. Cain says, “The minimal construction waste generated in the local fabrication of our steel components was immediately recycled versus the less certain future of waste generated in the use of off-the-shelf glue laminated beams or factory wastes generated in the manufacture of custom wood trusses. The roof of our structure covers 3,037 square feet---including eaves and overhangs---and the steel framing supports 2,834 square feet or 93% of the roof structure.”

The dramatic drilling of the four wells for the geothermal system was featured in the March 11, 2008 segment of the Discovery Channel’s Planet Green series that focuses on architecture “in synch with the planet”, Renovation Nation, with Emmy Award-winning host, Steve Thomas, formerly of This Old House.

LEED for Homes is an initiative designed to actively promote the transformation of the mainstream home building industry towards more sustainable practices. LEED for Homes is targeting the top 25% of new homes with best practice environmental features and is a collaborative initiative that actively works with all sectors of the home building industry. This home’s performance in regard to sustainable practices was measured in eight different resource categories:

1. Innovation and Design Process
2. Location and Linkages
3. Sustainable Sites
4. Water Efficiency
5. Improved Energy and Atmosphere
6. Use of environmentally preferable Materials and Resources
7. Indoor Environmental Quality
8. Public Awareness and Education.

The LEED for Homes rating system works by awarding credits for different aspects of environmental and energy efficient design in each of the above categories. The level of performance achieved in the above categories is separated into four performance tiers. LEED for Homes rates homes at one of the following levels: Certified, Silver, Gold or Platinum. Levels are awarded according to how many points the home achieves in the Rating System, with Platinum projects being the most exemplary environmentally/energy efficient structures on the planet. The Southface Institute, which served as LEED provider on this project, facilitates certification for all projects in Georgia, Alabama, Maryland, Washington DC, South Carolina, North Carolina, Tennessee and Mississippi. There are only four residential projects total in these states that have achieved the Platinum level --- with the RainShine House being the very first contemporary/modernist home.

The “green” aspects of this home extend to the landscaped site as well, designed by Lynn Saussy, RLA. New deciduous plantings will assist in shading the house in summer and allow sun to penetrate in winter. All new plantings on the site are exclusively native shrubs and grasses. Carefully placed rain gardens will collect site runoff while the delicately floating butterfly roof collects the rain for the rain harvest system. As the owners, and many of their visitors, are avid bicyclists, a bike rack was a necessary part of the site furniture. The grand Deodora Cedar on the site serves to shade the home from the western sun and planting two native Parsley Hawthorns will shade the southern sun but not the solar panels on the roof. [Editor: For a full description of the landscape strategies and plantings, visit the blog and click on Landscape http://rainshinehouseatlanta.blogspot.com ]

It’s hard to get greener than a house with glass curtain walls, re-purposed flooring and nontoxic paints, as well as carpet tiles and countertops made from recycled materials. To that, add super energy-efficient appliances; natural ventilation; the extensive use of natural daylight; water-conserving fixtures; a solar power-generating system; and much more. The home is nearly 100% non-toxic. When you walked into the house during construction all you could smell was the reclaimed heart-pine wood included in the design. One of the most important credits given this home by the LEED Program was for extraordinary performance in the selection of homeowner- and environment-friendly materials. To mention a few, all of the interior paints, stains, floor finishes, adhesives and sealants are either low-VOC or zero-VOC; the custom millwork is constructed of no-formaldehyde, 100% recycled-content MDF; the solar shades are zero-VOC; the concrete/glass countertops are 70% recycled; the wall insulation is formaldehyde-free; and, on the exterior, paints are also low-VOC, as is the siding; even the foundation waterproofing qualifies with a M.E.R.I.T. [Materials with Environmentally-Reduced Impact]-Certified Green system. As one of the owners is highly sensitive to toxins, the products used to clean the house after construction were Green Seal certified low-VOC.

No cute recycled accessories in this house, the very structure itself consists of major
recycled components such as the local concrete for the foundation which contains 30% fly ash, the reclaimed heart-pine flooring which is from the old Atlanta stables that were demolished and secured by Legacy Wood Products out of Watkinsville, Georgia. The massive exterior doors were custom-built from locally-salvaged Heart Pine. The beautiful concrete/glass countertops are 70% recycled content as is the colorful recycled glass backsplash. All tile flooring is 40% recycled content tiles [LEED gives a bonus half-point for no carpet in the home]. The exterior decking is manufactured from post-consumer recycled plastic and waste wood. The construction waste was recycled so the impact on the landfills was minimized, and as many construction materials as possible were extracted and manufactured locally, minimizing ozone depletion from heavy-truck transport to the site.

The owners wanted a “light-filled” home and their wishes were granted with walls of lowsolar- heat-gain coefficient glass. The owners wanted a “cheery” color scheme and so the architect-designed millwork is delicately colored in transparent blues, greens and yellows and the walls painted in soft sunshine yellows and light tree greens. Architect Cain said, “The owners were committed to a home that sits lightly on the earth and they have been 100% involved in this project throughout and bore a great deal of the burden in documenting the project for LEED qualification. I could not have asked for more positively involved clients.”

The design team, contractor and owners are celebrating Platinum at a dinner together. As anyone who has ever participated in a new home construction or home renovation will know, this happy gathering will be an uncharacteristic event.

Saturday, April 25, 2009

LEED for Homes Platinum Scorecard

Below is the official LEED for Homes Pilot Program Scorecard for the RainShine house.


LEED Facts 

The RainShine house 

Decatur, Georgia 

LEED for Homes Pilot Program 

Certification awarded April 15, 2009 

Platinum 108 

* 

Sustainable Sites 20/21 

Location and Linkages 8/10 

Water Efficiency 14/15 

Energy and Atmosphere 29/38 

Materials and Resources 11.5/14 

Indoor Environmental Quality 14/20 

Innovation and Design 9/9 

Awareness and Education 2/3 

*Out of a possible 130

Thursday, April 16, 2009

FLOR recycled Carpet Tiles

Area rugs made of Flor modular carpet tiles are used to define spaces and reiterate color choices throughout the house. The Flor products contain a high amount recycled content and allow completely customizable and designed rugs, making it the perfect choice for our LEED program house. The carpets are now installed, and the furniture is beginning to be moved into the house and arranged.



















Monday, March 16, 2009

Upcoming Tour

Join us May 2nd, 2009 for the Decatur Greenfest. Greenfest is a festival recognizing local "green" and organic products and services. The RainShine house is just blocks away from the Decatur Courthouse and will be featured during the festival for its LEED and environmentally-conscious components. The house will be open to the public, and the design team will be present to answer any questions about the house, the systems, the Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design (LEED) program or any other aspects of the house. Please email the office of Robert M. Cain, Architect for directions and specifics. We will see you there!

Friday, February 27, 2009

Recycled Glass Countertops

The countertops and back-splash combined contribute to 1 full point in the MR2B section of the LEED pilot program. They are considered EPP (Environmentally Preferable Products) and are sourced within 500 miles from the house. The recycled content of both is greater than 50% post-consumer products!



Wednesday, February 25, 2009

Blower Door Test






Monday, February 9, 2009

Salvaged Site Material

The existing driveway from the original demolished house was removed, crushed and placed around the new house as landscaping site fill.  This contributes to the Materials and Resources LEED points for repurposing existing site materials for the construction of the house.  




Wednesday, January 14, 2009

Millwork Construction Photos

The glues, stains, etc. are low VOC, and the MDF is 100% recycled content, each being 1/2 LEED point.  Therefore, the MDF contributes one whole point toward the RainShine LEED certification.  



Tuesday, January 6, 2009

Landscape Innovatives

The first innovative choice we made for the landscape was for a bicycle parking space. Our clients are avid bike riders and purposely only have one car between them. When designing for homeowners, we always have to accommodate for the automobile.  So why not provide the RainShine house with bicycle parking spaces to accommodate our clients’ lifestyle? We are proposing to use recycled granite curbs that the City has stockpiled as posts to support the bikes. The posts will have a hole drilled in them to receive a chain for securing the bike.

The other credits we hope to receive involves using 30% or greater fly ash and slag in our large entry concrete stepping stones. We also are using recycled granite curbs for steps off the deck and locally crushed slate chips as landings between the granite steps and entry stepping stones.

-  Lynn Saussy, Landscape Architect

Energy and Atmosphere

We met the lighting requirement by placing, in the garden entry, four wireless photovoltaic exterior light fixtures.

-  Lynn Saussy, Landscape Architect

Surface Water Management and Water Efficiency

Another new experience for me was designing rain gardens for rain harvesting. This is how we decided to handle storm water runoff from the impervious surfaces we proposed. We have one rain garden in between the recycled brick driveway strips and two larger rain gardens located downhill from the house before the storm water reaches the stream. All are planted with drought tolerant native species. To be water efficient and eliminate an irrigation system, any new tree and shrub plantings will be watered by a hose connected to the rain barrels.

-  Lynn Saussy, Landscape Architect

Shading of Hardscapes

On this site, the only hardscape to shade was the house and the driveway. Our grand Deodora Cedar served to shade the home from the western sun and we are planting two native Parsley Hawthorns to shade the southern sun (we chose these native trees because they will only grow + 20' height which will not shade the solar panels on the roof). We only had 20 linear feet of driveway to shade and we accomplished that with a Native Dogwood.

- Lynn Saussy, Landscape Architect

Sustainable Sites

After reading through the LEED manual, it was apparent we needed to eliminate all turf and use all drought tolerant native grasses and perennials. We could 'build' a meadow! How 'green' is that?

First inspiration was drawn from Oehme van Sweden's 'designed meadow' style and the cost of installing a meadow was researched. When presented at our next team meeting this solution proved to be too expensive. In order to have a successful meadow, you must plant the grasses and perennials quite close to keep the invasive species from germinating and overpowering the native species. Invasives choke out the native species since they grow faster and larger. The quantity of materials needed blew the budget. A disappointment for everyone.

So back to the drawing board.....what would be more cost efficient? Ah ha! What if we let the site go back to its natural state - a woodland/forest? There are plenty of dormant seeds in the soil as well as ones delivered by the wind and birds. This would take patience to develop and constant maintenance to control the invasives that geminated but it is an inexpensive and progressive solution. When presented to the team, everyone agreed it is a perfect solution for this project.

And as it turns out, the woodland/forest is one of the owners' favorite landscapes.

The original plant communities of this area are of two types: Midslope Forest and Mesic Forest.

The species in the first type are dominated by White Oak, Post Oak, Southern Red Oak, Pignut Hickory with understory trees such as Dogwood, Sourwood, Blackgum, and American Holly. The shrubs include low various blueberries, dwarf Paw Paw and Strawberry bush.

The second type, Mesic Forest, has many of the same canopy species but the notable presence of the American Beech, Tulip Poplar and Northern Red Oak dominate. The shrub layer includes Wild Hydrangea, Piedmont Azaleas and Musclewood.

Now how to get there?? Our first step to re-create the woodland/forest is to build a rich organic soil 'floor'. We will accomplish this by simply covering the bare areas with clean wood chips, leave it for a year or two and remove the invasives as they appear. The only plantings we are specifying now are going to cover any of the steep slopes to prevent erosion and use only native shrubs and grasses.

First piece of the puzzle solved! On to the next ones......

- Lynn Saussy, Landscape Architect

Thursday, December 18, 2008

On-Site Recycling, Waste Management

The RainShine House received 18 points toward the LEED certification under the LEED MR3.2 and Earthcraft waste management guidelines. These guidelines require a waste management plan to be implemented on the site during construction. Strategies include chipping and recycling formwork, drywall, etc. as seen in the photos below. One requirement states that the plan must be clearly labeled on site, as seen on the containment area in the photo below. For more information on Earthcraft requirements, please visit their website.